Pages: [1]   Go Down
Print
Author Topic: New Whey Protein Contains High Fat Content  (Read 142 times)
ChangeIsLife
Applying Gnome


Reputation Power: 1
ChangeIsLife is starting out.
Posts: 4


View Profile Awards
« on: January 27, 2012, 08:27:17 AM »

I ordered a new whey protein from the internet to save some money, and when I got the stuff in the mail the label reads 5g (5%) of fat per scoop.  This is at least DOUBLE the fat content that I find in most whey proteins, if not more.

I have no doubt that this whey protein can still help build muscle... but is it counter productive to weight loss considering the high fat content... and could it still be used to- at the very least- maintain a lean body, considering I keep a regular 3-day per week resistance routine and a 2 day per week cardio routine w/ rest on the weekends)?

Also, do you think that using this whey would have negative effects during my rest periods (where I am doing no resistance with very minimal cardio for a couple weeks or so)?

Thanks in advance for all your replies. All thoughts and questions are welcome.
Logged
Uglok
Übergnome
****

Reputation Power: 33
Uglok is a rising star!Uglok is a rising star!Uglok is a rising star!Uglok is a rising star!Uglok is a rising star!Uglok is a rising star!
Posts: 4605

All I know is that I know nothing.

  • Awards Member of the Month Winner Given for tirelessly and competently discussing and answering questions. Given for excellent postings explaining ideas and concepts.

  • View Profile Awards
    « Reply #1 on: January 27, 2012, 08:34:23 AM »

    Yes, of course it can. 5g fat per scoop (which wouldn't be 5% unless your scoop is 100g) is only 45 Calories or so, which is nothing.
    Logged

    ChangeIsLife
    Applying Gnome


    Reputation Power: 1
    ChangeIsLife is starting out.
    Posts: 4


    View Profile Awards
    « Reply #2 on: January 27, 2012, 10:27:44 AM »

    Sorry, label says:

    1 scoop = 36 g

    160 calories

    fat = 5 g (8%) (it says 8%, sorry bout that)


    I know you say it's nothing, considering it's only 45 calories and all... but 30 calories of that 160 are from fat, and if you spread that out to 6 meals per day, and I typically add a scoop of this stuff to at least half of those meals, then what you get is an additional effect.  True that most of the time those meals are very healthy (such as oatmeal & 100% whole wheat cereal).

    Do you think I am nit-picking about this too much and shouldn't have to worry about it if I'm eating healthy in general?
    Logged
    Uglok
    Übergnome
    ****

    Reputation Power: 33
    Uglok is a rising star!Uglok is a rising star!Uglok is a rising star!Uglok is a rising star!Uglok is a rising star!Uglok is a rising star!
    Posts: 4605

    All I know is that I know nothing.

  • Awards Member of the Month Winner Given for tirelessly and competently discussing and answering questions. Given for excellent postings explaining ideas and concepts.

  • View Profile Awards
    « Reply #3 on: January 27, 2012, 10:31:48 AM »

    Yes I think you're nitpicking lol - several things:

     - It doesn't matter whether the calories come from carbohydrates or fat, especially not when you're dealing with such a small figure. They end up the same way.

     - You're having at least 3 scoops of protein powder a day. This should not be necessary, hell these 3 alone will likely provide your protein requirement for the day - something's wrong here.

     - It's 160 Calories per scoop, 45 from fat.


    You can kill yourself with the anxiety of worrying about eating such things; fat is healthy and essential, these minute quantities won't amount to anything you can notice.
    Logged

    fabbe
    Übergnome
    ****

    Reputation Power: 1
    fabbe is starting out.
    Posts: 1549



    View Profile Awards
    « Reply #4 on: January 27, 2012, 10:32:21 AM »

    Give it back to the store, that is waaay to much fat!
    Logged

    ChangeIsLife
    Applying Gnome


    Reputation Power: 1
    ChangeIsLife is starting out.
    Posts: 4


    View Profile Awards
    « Reply #5 on: January 27, 2012, 10:44:57 AM »

    Yes I think you're nitpicking lol - several things:

     - It doesn't matter whether the calories come from carbohydrates or fat, especially not when you're dealing with such a small figure. They end up the same way.

     - You're having at least 3 scoops of protein powder a day. This should not be necessary, hell these 3 alone will likely provide your protein requirement for the day - something's wrong here.

     - It's 160 Calories per scoop, 45 from fat.


    You can kill yourself with the anxiety of worrying about eating such things; fat is healthy and essential, these minute quantities won't amount to anything you can notice.


    Thanks for your reply... I know that fat is essential, but scooby teaches us that no more than 10% of the calories in the food we eat should come from fat when operating under a muscle-gain/lose-fat diet.  I agree that one scoop out of the meal is a very small number, and while my inclination is to think that this really won't have a significant effect, the health nut part of me is paranoid that this could have negative effects.

    Here is Scooby's video on label reading, which describes that no more than 10% of the calories in your meal should be from fat... granted that this scoop doesn't constitute the entire meal: Reading Nutritional Labels

    This video also demonstrates that for a 160 lbs person, an intake of 160 grams of protein spread throughout the day is necessary... so I disagree when you say that the three meals above alone are enough to satisfy the daily protein quota.

    Here is also another nutritional video where he demonstrates that adding whey protein to multiple meals per day is not wrong, and is necessary for people who don't have the time to plan out their meals on a regular basis every single day: Healthy meals for students and other busy people: 6-pack abs and gain muscle with good nutrition

    Again, thanks for your responses.   I'm only looking for answers.  Maybe I should try and reach Scooby directly for this one.
    Logged
    Uglok
    Übergnome
    ****

    Reputation Power: 33
    Uglok is a rising star!Uglok is a rising star!Uglok is a rising star!Uglok is a rising star!Uglok is a rising star!Uglok is a rising star!
    Posts: 4605

    All I know is that I know nothing.

  • Awards Member of the Month Winner Given for tirelessly and competently discussing and answering questions. Given for excellent postings explaining ideas and concepts.

  • View Profile Awards
    « Reply #6 on: January 27, 2012, 10:48:33 AM »

    Scooby is not a god, and Scooby is not always right. Most people don't require the 1g protein per 1lb bodyweight at all.

    Since those videos were released, I have also seen Scooby up his calories-from-fat recommendation to 20% and his protein recommendation to 1g per lb of lean bodyweight. In either case, unless actually obese I see no need to restrict % calories from fat this meticulously (3000 excess Calories from carbohydrates will turn to bodyfat just as readily as 3000 excess Calories of dietary fat!) and as a rule of thumb the vast majority of people are getting more than enough protein if they are consuming above 100g per day.
    Logged

    ChangeIsLife
    Applying Gnome


    Reputation Power: 1
    ChangeIsLife is starting out.
    Posts: 4


    View Profile Awards
    « Reply #7 on: January 27, 2012, 10:53:50 AM »

    Thank you for your response.  I feel better knowing I don't have to let 10 lbs of protein powder go to waste lol  ; )
    Logged
    Pages: [1]   Go Up
    Print
    Jump to: