Pages: [1]   Go Down
Print
Author Topic: Women's body fat & BMI  (Read 1467 times)
omatsu123
Regular Gnome
**

Reputation Power: 1
omatsu123 is starting out.
Posts: 262

  • Awards Given for outstanding fitness progress

  • View Profile Awards
    « on: February 24, 2011, 11:30:57 PM »

    Currently, my BF is around 15% which is very low for women.But I'm feeling pretty okay and can workout and climb comfortably. I'm not trying to lose fat now but working out harder than ever to be a better climber. I do not recommend any woman to be at this low BF.



    However, I kind of feel as long as your BMI is within suitable range, low BF doesn't matter so much. In fact, makes you ripped and feel good about yourself.

    My BMI is 20, right in normal range. What's your take? I'd like to hear especially from men who's BF is less than 10%.

    Logged
    JuhQman
    Icegnome
    Übergnome
    ****

    Reputation Power: 2
    JuhQman is starting out.
    Posts: 1240


    zOmg


    View Profile Awards
    « Reply #1 on: February 24, 2011, 11:36:59 PM »

    I think BMI is a lousy meter. With enough muscle even people with extremely low BF% might be described as overweight. I think Ruben said that his BMR is on the slightly overweight part. And that guy is RIPPED.

    In the end I think the best gauge is you. If you feel comfortable with your current BF% and weight then that should be more than enough.
    Logged

    My flab-a-licious progress diary

    The great masses of the people... will more easily fall victims to a big lie than to a small one

    Tell me what you eat, and I will tell you what you are
    omatsu123
    Regular Gnome
    **

    Reputation Power: 1
    omatsu123 is starting out.
    Posts: 262

  • Awards Given for outstanding fitness progress

  • View Profile Awards
    « Reply #2 on: February 25, 2011, 10:59:41 AM »

    In the end I think the best gauge is you. If you feel comfortable with your current BF% and weight then that should be more than enough.

    JuhQman, I absolutely agree with you. However, there are so many women who starve themselves to go extremely low BMI and go extremely low BF%.

    Ideally, to get 6 pac abs, you need to aim to less then 20% for women. But for those with very low BMI, when they go less than 20%, they get only boney belly not 6 pac abs.
    Or low BMI and low BF% but still ugly love handles.

    You wouldn't believe it but there is a slim madness in Japan. These people do not realize that they are slowly killing themselves with starvation diet. And I thought BMI is a suitable meter as far as health is concerned.

    Maybe higher BMI is okay. But when you are lower BMI, it is a problem.
    Logged
    Goldie
    Moderator
    Hypergnome
    *****

    Reputation Power: 41
    Goldie is a force to reckon with.Goldie is a force to reckon with.Goldie is a force to reckon with.Goldie is a force to reckon with.Goldie is a force to reckon with.Goldie is a force to reckon with.Goldie is a force to reckon with.Goldie is a force to reckon with.
    Posts: 5918



    View Profile Awards
    « Reply #3 on: February 25, 2011, 12:33:48 PM »

    The BMI was invented to give average people an idea of where they stand, weight/health-wise.

    It's not a very good indicator of fitness, though. As JuhQ said, a very muscular person with low BF% will get an "overweight" number. And someone whose number says they're "normal weight" could have very little muscle and a high BF%.

    Here's a link that explains some of the limitations ---> BMI Limitations

    It's a quick and easy tool, although maybe too easy!
    Logged

    You make your choices, and you live with them. In the end, you are those choices.
    omatsu123
    Regular Gnome
    **

    Reputation Power: 1
    omatsu123 is starting out.
    Posts: 262

  • Awards Given for outstanding fitness progress

  • View Profile Awards
    « Reply #4 on: February 25, 2011, 05:42:11 PM »

    Thanks, Goldie.

    I guess I worded my question wrongly. I wanted to say you have to have certain amount of weight for 6 pac abs. I checked my favorite female body builders and they are slim but do have some weight.

    Ava Cowan 5.4f(164cm), 125lbs(54kg), BMI20
    Jillian Michael 5.2f(158cm), 120lbs(54kg), BMI20
    Lisette Valdes 5.4f(164cm), 125lbs(54kg), BMI20

    So I wanted to say when you are lower than BMI 20, you won't get 6 pac abs even if your BF% goes less than 20%. Rather you will look too skinny or boney.

    I guess I understand the limitation of BMI but it has some use when telling you are too skinny or enough weight.
    Logged
    oliver
    Regular Gnome
    **

    Reputation Power: 1
    oliver is starting out.
    Posts: 410



    View Profile Awards
    « Reply #5 on: February 27, 2011, 05:09:09 AM »

    I just realised how wrong it is for male competitive bodybuilders.

    Ronnie Coleman when competing was 135kg and 1.75m tall. That gives him a BMI of 44.1! That would classify him as being morbidly obese, whilst he would actually have an extremely low BF. Although he was on steroids.....

    Still natural bodybuilders that have been working out for a while (3+ years) could quite easily probably be considered overweight or obese, which is quite obviously wrong.

    BMI scale I believe is quite inaccurate it would differ greatly for people with different builds (eg stocky build vs slim build)
    Logged

    My progress diary! http://www.askscooby.com/progress-diaries/olis-progress-full-body-workouts/30/

    Goals by 2012:

    110kg Bench Press 1 RM
    180kg Sumo Deadlift 1 RM
    160kg Squat 1RM
    Pages: [1]   Go Up
    Print
    Jump to: